Plomin Power Station Unit C, Croatia

National and international NGOs and local citizens said NO to construction of the new coal power plant Plomin C and demanded from the Croatian Government to invest in renewable energy sources instead.


Description
Plomin Power Station is located near town Plomin on Croatian peninsula Istria. The power station is owned and managed by the state company Hrvatska elektroprivreda d.d. (HEP d.d.). It is a coal fired power station consisted of two boiler units A (built in 1969) and B (built in 2000), with capacities of 120 MW and 210 MW, respectively. The Plomin Power Station produces 12% of Croatia’s electricity needs. In 2011, the management of the plant announced the plan for reconstruction of the unit A and construction of a new unit of 500MW named Plomin C. However, this plan has been rejected and strongly opposed by the local, national and international environmental NGOs that claimed that such project will make impossible to make long-terms cut in GHG emissions, which Croatia is obligated to do as a member of European Union. Also, the opponents of the project highlight that according to Croatian Spatial Planning Program from 1999 there should not be built any thermal power plant fueled by coal until the year 2015. Moreover, according to the actual spatial plan, on the location planned for building the Plomin C, there's a permission to build a gas power plant, with maximum capacity of 125 MW. Additionally, in 2013 the local branch of the Greenpeace did a case study on hidden cost of planned coal-fired power plant, which revealed many health and environmental drawbacks of the proposed project. The Ministry of Environmental and Nature Protection of the Republic of Croatia, however, allowed building of the Plomin C. In June 2013, Istria County together with two NGOs Zelena Istra (Green Istria) and Zelena Akcija (Green Action), and some individual citizens filed a legal suit against the Ministry. In October 2013 the Administrative Court in City of Rijeka refused to bring charges against the Ministry for procedural omissions in EIA. In March 2015, 36% of citizen of Labinština region participated in a referendum and 94% of them voted against the project. However, the results were not accepted by the government because the turnover was less than 50%.  The Croatian government selected as the project investors Japanese company Marubeni and French company Alstom, both accused for corruption. According to the contract with the investor, HEP would buy at least 50% of electricity produced in Plomin C paying 85 euros per MWh which is three-time higher prices than electricity available on the European market. In September 2015, NGOs sent a letter to the European Commission pointing on that contract conditions are contrary to EU competition law. Thereafter, the European Commission informed HEP on a negative opinion on the proposed agreement. In addition, NGOs protested in front to the Crédit Agricole offices in Croatia and France given that this bank was contracted as a financial advisory on the project. The new bank policy forbade its participation in financing of coal power plants in countries with a high GDP, including Croatia. In January 2016, the Croatian government announced a temporary moratorium on the Plomin C. As it has been written in the newspapers, the government is not giving up on Plomin C and it is looking for a way to be consistent with the EU rules. Therefore, until now no official  and permanent decision has been rendered and the future of the Plomin C project is still unknown.
Basic Data
NamePlomin Power Station Unit C, Croatia
CountryCroatia
ProvinceIstria County
SitePlomin
Accuracy of LocationHIGH local level
Source of Conflict
Type of Conflict (1st level)Fossil Fuels and Climate Justice/Energy
Type of Conflict (2nd level)Thermal power plants
Specific CommoditiesElectricity
Coal
Project Details and Actors
Project Details
Unit C would have power of 500MW, lifetime of 25 years, and annual production of electrical energy 3.608 GWh.
See more...
Level of Investment (in USD)800,000,000
Type of PopulationSemi-urban
Start Date28/03/2012
Company Names or State EnterprisesHrvatska elektroprivreda d.d. (HEP d.d.) from Croatia - The owner of the Plomin Power Station
Marubeni from Japan - Selected investor
Alstom from France - Selected investor
Relevant government actorsThe Ministry of Environmental and Nature Protection of the Republic of Croatia; The Istria County
International and Financial InstitutionsCredit Agricole CIB from France
Environmental justice organisations and other supportersNGO Zaustavimo Plomin C https://www.facebook.com/zaustavimoplominc/?fref=ts; Zelena Istra (Green Istria) http://www.zelena-istra.hr; Zelena Akcija (Green Action) http://zelena-akcija.hr/en; Greenpeace http://www.greenpeace.org/international/en/; Heinrich Böll Stiftung http://www.boell.org; Friends of the Earth France https://www.foeeurope.org/france; Friends of the Earth Colombia http://www.foei.org/member-groups/latin-america-and-the-caribbean/colombia; Re:Common; Bankwatch http://bankwatch.org/; Citizens of Lebiština
The Conflict and the Mobilization
Intensity of Conflict (at highest level)MEDIUM (street protests, visible mobilization)
When did the mobilization beginPREVENTIVE resistance (precautionary phase)
Groups MobilizingInternational ejos
Local ejos
Local government/political parties
Neighbours/citizens/communities
Local scientists/professionals
Forms of MobilizationArtistic and creative actions (eg guerilla theatre, murals)
Creation of alternative reports/knowledge
Development of a network/collective action
Development of alternative proposals
Involvement of national and international NGOs
Lawsuits, court cases, judicial activism
Media based activism/alternative media
Objections to the EIA
Official complaint letters and petitions
Public campaigns
Referendum other local consultations
Impacts
Environmental ImpactsVisible: Air pollution, Global warming, Loss of landscape/aesthetic degradation, Oil spills, Surface water pollution / Decreasing water (physico-chemical, biological) quality
Potential: Biodiversity loss (wildlife, agro-diversity), Soil contamination
Health ImpactsVisible: Exposure to unknown or uncertain complex risks (radiation, etc…), Accidents
Potential: Other environmental related diseases, Other Health impacts, Deaths
OtherThe results of Greenpeace study on the health impacts of Plomin C suggest that its construction would cause 17 deaths, 2,671 asthma attacks and more than 36,000 cases of respiratory disease annually. In addition, during its expected lifespan of 40 years the coal power plant would be responsible for as many as 1,000 deaths.
Socio-economic ImpactsPotential: Increase in Corruption/Co-optation of different actors, Loss of landscape/sense of place
OtherAccording to the Greenpeace study, the total external cost from pollution would be 150 million USA per year.

A new economic analysis commissioned by Zelena akcija and carried out by the Society for Sustainable Development Design (DOOR) using European Commission methodology confirms that Plomin C is economically unfeasible.
Outcome
Project StatusPlanned (decision to go ahead eg EIA undertaken, etc)
Pathways for conflict outcome / responseCourt decision (failure for environmental justice)
Under negotiation
Moratoria
Withdrawal of company/investment
Project temporarily suspended
Development of AlternativesNGOs demand permanent moratorium on Plomin C. They consider this project unmoral, unjust and perpetuating Croatia’s energy dependence on external sources. In general, they are against the use of coal for power production and demanded from the government to create conditions for massive investment in energy efficiency and renewables, in particular solar energy. NGOs also demanded from government to listen to the democratic will of the citizens demonstrated in the referendum. They also asked for more transparency on the conditions negotiated between HEP and the investor, as well as in communicating further plans on Plomin C.
Do you consider this as a success?Not Sure
Why? Explain briefly.Currently, there is a temporary moratorium on the project issued by the new government. However, the government is still looking for the conditions to realize the project under the conditions acceptable by the European Commission. In the past, the Administrative Court in City of Rijeka refused to bring charges against the Ministry of Environmental and Nature Protection for procedural omissions in EIA.
Sources and Materials
References

Greenpeace report on Plomin C
[click to view]

THE PLOMIN C COAL PLANT: Analysis of compatibility with Crédit Agricole energy policies
[click to view]

Links

HEP selects Marubeni as Preferred Bidder for Plomin C coal-fired power plant
[click to view]

Plomin C coal power plant BANCKTRACK
[click to view]

Termoelektranu će graditi Marubeni: HEP za gradnju i upravljanje Plominom C odabrao Japance
[click to view]

Struju iz Plomina C japanski Marubeni bi HEP-u prodavao po upola višoj cijeni od tržišne
[click to view]

New Government, Fossil Solutions?
[click to view]

TE Plomin C to cause as many as 680 premature deaths over 40 years
[click to view]

Greenpeace ship in action against the thermpopower plant "Plomin C"
[click to view]

Green Action firmly opposed to the coal power plant Plomin
[click to view]

Croatian green groups mount legal challenge on "Plomin C" coal power plant
[click to view]

Zelena akcija potencijalni ulagaci u Plomin c kaznjavani zbog korupcije
[click to view]

Zeleni nastavljaju borbu protiv izgradnje Plomina c
[click to view]

Various links on Plomin C, Novilist
[click to view]

Plomin C nije dobio prolaz u Bruxellesu
[click to view]

Expert analysis confirms Croatian Plomin C coal plant is economically unfeasible
[click to view]

Građani traže kraj fosile ere – trajno odustanite od Plomina C i bušenja Jadrana!
[click to view]

Most i HDZ se složili da Plomin C treba graditi
[click to view]

Ministar poduzetništva Horvat: "Plomin C nam sigurno treba"
[click to view]

RATKO BOŠKOVIĆ Gradnja TE Plomin-C na ugljen Labinštini je zapravo protuzakonito podmetnuta
[click to view]

International action in Plomin: activists called on the Croatian Government to give up on coal import and the construction of “Plomin C
[click to view]

Zelena akcija: Plomin C ekonomski je neisplativ projekt
[click to view]

Niska cijena ugljena pogurat će Plomin C
[click to view]

10 September 2015 - Crédit Agricole's answer to Amis de la Terre Plomin C
[click to view]

New Croatian government may scrap plans for Plomin-C power plant
[click to view]

Croatia, Italy and Colombia linked by harm from coal industry
[click to view]

http://zelena-akcija.hr/hr/programi/energetika_i_klimatske_promjene/moratorij_na_plomin_c_istinski_stav_ili_prva_obmana_nove_vlade
[click to view]

Europska komisija ne dopušta potpisivanje ugovora za Plomin C
[click to view]

Uspjeh u kampanji protiv Plomina C - Crédit Agricole se povlači
[click to view]

Zrak onečišćen oko Plomina i Koromačna
[click to view]

Plomin C related articles
[click to view]

Koruptivne aktivnosti izvođača radova Plomina C
[click to view]

Informacija: Iz TE Plomin istekla nafta u more
[click to view]

Informacija: Iz TE Plomin istekla nafta u more
[click to view]

Koruptivne aktivnosti izvođača radova Plomina C
[click to view]

Marubeni spreman za Plomin C
[click to view]

Croatia's HEP, Japan's Marubeni talks on Plomin C project close to wrapup - report
[click to view]

Građanima je dosta Plomina C – korumpirane tvrtke, skupa struja, štetan utjecaj na zdravlje...
[click to view]

Otkupnu cijenu struje HEP taji od javnosti
[click to view]

Volju građana Vlada ne smije ignorirati
[click to view]

Međunarodnom akcijom aktivisti pozvali Vladu da odustane od uvoza ugljena i izgradnje Plomina C
[click to view]

23% birača je dovoljno za formiranje Vlade RH, a 35% nije dovoljno da odluči o Plominu C?
[click to view]

Nova tribina o „Plominu C“ – 29.03. svi na referendum!
[click to view]

Stručna analiza potvrdila: Čak i uz zanemarivanje utjecaja na zdravlje i okoliš, Plomin C je ekonomski neisplativ projekt!
[click to view]

Media Links

Greenpeace upozorava na štetnost Termoelektrane Plomin C
[click to view]

Plomin C: Prava cijena ugljena 4
[click to view]

Plomin C: Prava cijena ugljena 3
[click to view]

Video against Plomin C
[click to view]

Tribina SKRIVENI TROŠKOVI TE PLOMIN C
[click to view]

STOP Plomin C
[click to view]

Other Documents

Greenpeace protest against Plomin C The banner reads: “64% of the citizens are against Plomin C”
[click to view]

Activistst of Green Action and Heinrich Böll Stiftung in protest against Plomin C The sign reads: “New government, fossil solutions?”
[click to view]

Protest in front of the Croatian government The activists have been demanding from the government to respect the results of a referendum in which 94% of the citizens were against Plomin C.
[click to view]

Meta Information
ContributorJovanka Spiric, Universitat Autónoma de Barcelona, vankajo(at)gmail.com
Last update07/05/2016
Comments