Please zoom in or out and select the base layer according to your preference to make the map ready for printing, then press the Print button above.

Samarco Tailings Dam Disaster, Minas Gerais, Brazil


Description:

The Brazilian governments under Presidents Lula and Rousseff pushed forward an exporting extractivist economy largely based on iron ore exports by the Vale S.A. company (formely Vale de Rio Doce) and also on soybean exports. To the Brazilian policy makers (both in government and in the neoliberal opposition) the tailings dams failure at Samarco's Germano mine (Samarco is owned by Vale and BHP Billiton) in Mariana (not far from Ouro Preto), in Minas Gerais’ iron belt on 5th November 2015 was something of a shock. This is one of the largest iron ore mines in the world. The Rio Doce (the Doce River) was polluted for over 700 km downstream. The burst dam unleashed 50 million cubic meters of mud on the valley killing 19 people and wiping out the village of Bento Rodrigues and reaching very quickly Barra Longa and other villages. About 800 people lost their homes. Many villages downstream were left without drinkable water. The discharges were mainly composed of iron oxide and silica, but IBAMA reports indicate their toxic potential by the presence of heavy metals [14].

Dilma Rousseff compared the Samarco disaster with the BP 2010 Deepwater Horizon spill in the Gulf of Mexico. She said that Samarco’s shareholders — BHP Billiton, the Anglo-Australian company, and the Brazilian iron ore exporter Vale — would pay for the accident but the figures mentioned by Roussef were pitifully low, not billions but tens of millions of dolars. The Financial Times reported that there was concern over the size of liabilities associated with the accident. An analyst at Citi said that: “It could possibly cost BHP more than $1bn with the clean-up costs, potential fines from government and compensation to families.” [9]. BHP Billiton has 50% share in Samarco.

The Unions had complained that Vale was lowering safety standards.

Workers feared for their safety after the Samarco dam burst, where the company was reducing the number of employees because of weak ore prices, despite its push for output and complaints about safety. Ronilton Condessa, secretary of the Metabase labor union in Mariana, where Samarco is the main employer, told Reuters that nearly 400 mine workers were dismissed in 2015 from Vale's mining complex of Mariana, even as it squeezed more productivity from the workforce to offset the drop in revenue from iron ore sales to the global steel industry. The company unearths 10 percent of its total iron output of roughly 340 million tonnes a year there. Vale has four mines in the Mariana Complex around Samarco: the Algeria, Fabrica Nova, Vazendao and Timbopeba mines, where it employs 3,000 people. The Metabase union represents workers at the first three of those mines [10].

Vale had been pushing output to record levels in the face of sagging prices, as it is fighting for the No. 1 slot in iron ore against its Australian rivals BHP and Rio Tinto. "Hiring is happening only in exceptional cases," Condessa said. He said union members have complained about undue pressure to ramp up production [10].

The MAB (movement of “atingidos por barragens”) and the International Articulation of “Atingidos pela Vale” issued statements [4, 5]. The latter said, “The rupture of a tailings dam – a structure that is intended to retain the solid waste, which has a high level of toxicity and water from ore beneficiation processes – does not occur randomly and is not new in the state Minas Gerais, nor in the mining sector. The severity of the case requires rigorous investigation into the incident, strict accountability of perpetrators and full redress and compensation to all affected”. Pollution would reach the state of Espírito Santo and the sea, through the Rio Doce. They added that what happened was a crime. The regulatory agencies and companies had full responsibility for the tragedy. The amount of waste proved that companies had passed the dam’s capacity. The technical report conducted by the Instituto Prístino at the request of the public prosecutor during the licensing of the project had already identified problems, such as the dam of Fundão (that failed) and the waste dump Union Fábrica Nova Mine Vale which border on each other, with overlapping areas of direct influence [5].

Indigenous Krenak people cut the railway from Minas Gerais to the harbour Vitoria in Espírito Santo for a few days to complain against the pollution of the Rio Doce. This is a route followed by the iron ore for export [1, 2]. For the Krenaks, the Rio Doce was source of their subsistence and also a sacred entity [15]. In January 2016, the Tupinikim and Guarani Mbyá indigenous also protested on the Vitória-Minas Railroad (EFVM) in order to draw attention to the impacts on their communities. The protests also contributed to their recognition as being affected by the disaster [16].

In March 2016, the Brazilian federal government and the state governments of Minas Gerais and Espírito Santo signed a "Term of Transaction and Adjustment of Conduct" (TTAC) with Samarco, Vale and BHP. The agreement determined the reparation measures, which would have an estimated cost of US$ 5 billion to be applied over 15 years, and the creation of the Renova Foundation to manage the reparation and compensation actions [11]. However, the negotiations that led to this agreement completely ignored the populations affected by the disaster [18]. According to a statement of “Atingidos pela Vale”: “The agreement signed between Samarco, Vale and BHP, the states of Minas Gerais and Espírito Santo and the federal government was the result of the power of the companies and the interest of the State in speeding up alleged remedial measures and hiding their responsibilities. The political influence of companies and the complicity of the State tried to affirm a minimal agreement of mitigation of the impacts, that ignored the participation of the victims of this great disaster.” [17].

The TACC was also criticized by the Federal Public Defender's Office (DPU) and the Public Prosecutor's Office of Minas Gerais and the Federal Public Ministry. The latter filed a Public Civil Action in May 2016 against Samarco, Vale and BHP, and against the Union and the States of Minas Gerais and Espírito Santo so that they would be required to fully repair the social, economic and environmental consequences of the disruption. The repair value was estimated at $ 43.8 billion (based on the Deepwater Horizon disaster figures). Another Public Civil Action of US$ 5 billion against the companies had been filed in 2015 by the Federal Government, but would be extinguished with the approval of the agreement. Finally, the TACC was ratified in May 2016, but suspended by the Supreme Court of Justice (STJ) on July 2016 [11, 13].

In January 2017, a Preliminary Adjustment Term (TAP), with the participation of affected communities, defined the hiring of research centers to carry out specialized expertise and evaluate the impacts of the tragedy. In 2018, a new Adjustment and Conduct Term was elaborated, which was called Governance TAC, which considered the increase of the participation of the victims in the processes of deliberation related to reparations and in the Renova Foundation. With the approval of the agreement, the Public Civil Action of $ 43.8 billion was provisionally suspended for up to two years [13]. This new agreement was criticized by the “Movimento dos Atingidos por Barragens” for having been rebuilt without dialogue with those affected by the disaster, despite some advances in participation, and for keeping them as minorities in all decision-making bodies [12].

The Federal Police (PF) and the Minas Gerais State Public Prosecutor presented a criminal proceeding related to the disaster at the beginning of June 2016. In the ongoing proceeding, 22 people – members of the Board of Directors of Vale and BHP, directors and managers of Samarco, representatives of Vale and BHP in Samarco and engineers of VogBR Consulting – are charged with murder, flooding, collapse, bodily injury and environmental crimes. In this same criminal proceeding, VogBR is responsible for the crime of filing a false environmental report, and Samarco, Vale and BHP Billiton are accused of nine environmental crimes [20].

Basic Data

Name of conflict:Samarco Tailings Dam Disaster, Minas Gerais, Brazil
Country:Brazil
State or province:Minas Gerais
Location of conflict:Mariana
Accuracy of locationHIGH (Local level)

Source of Conflict

Type of conflict: 1st level:Mineral Ores and Building Materials Extraction
Type of conflict: 2nd level :Tailings from mines
Dams and water distribution conflicts
Specific commodities:Iron ore

Project Details and Actors

Project details:

In 2014, Samarco produced 25 million tons of iron ore in Mariana, and a similar amount of waste. Production increased 9 million tons over previous year, to compensate for lower prices.

Some early reports cited in The Financial Times put the liability for the tailings dams failure at one billion USD. The legal developments (including criminal charges) and the amounts of money being considered for compensation (exceeding USD 40 billion) are described above, under Source of Conflict.

Project area:30,000
Type of populationSemi-urban
Affected Population:40,000
Start of the conflict:05/11/2015
Company names or state enterprises:Samarco from Brazil
BHP Billiton (BHP) from United Kingdom
Vale (Vale) from Brazil
Relevant government actors:Governor of Minas Gerais
President of Brazil
Ministry of Mines, Brazil
Environmental justice organizations (and other supporters) and their websites, if available:Atingidos por Barragens
Articulacao Internacional de Atingidos pela Vale
Metabase, workers union in Mariana, Minas Gerais

Conflict and Mobilization

IntensityHIGH (widespread, mass mobilization, violence, arrests, etc...)
Reaction stageMobilization for reparations once impacts have been felt
Groups mobilizing:Farmers
Indigenous groups or traditional communities
International ejos
Local ejos
Local government/political parties
Neighbours/citizens/communities
Social movements
Trade unions
Ethnically/racially discriminated groups
Local scientists/professionals
Forms of mobilization:Creation of alternative reports/knowledge
Development of a network/collective action
Involvement of national and international NGOs
Lawsuits, court cases, judicial activism
Media based activism/alternative media
Official complaint letters and petitions
Public campaigns
Street protest/marches

Impacts of the project

Environmental ImpactsVisible: Biodiversity loss (wildlife, agro-diversity), Floods (river, coastal, mudflow), Loss of landscape/aesthetic degradation, Waste overflow, Deforestation and loss of vegetation cover, Surface water pollution / Decreasing water (physico-chemical, biological) quality, Groundwater pollution or depletion, Large-scale disturbance of hydro and geological systems, Mine tailing spills, Reduced ecological / hydrological connectivity, Soil contamination
Health ImpactsVisible: Exposure to unknown or uncertain complex risks (radiation, etc…), Mental problems including stress, depression and suicide, Occupational disease and accidents, Deaths, Other environmental related diseases, Accidents
Socio-economical ImpactsVisible: Displacement, Lack of work security, labour absenteeism, firings, unemployment, Loss of livelihood, Violations of human rights, Land dispossession, Loss of landscape/sense of place

Outcome

Project StatusUnknown
Conflict outcome / response:Compensation
Migration/displacement
Under negotiation
Project temporarily suspended
Development of alternatives:Iron mining was suspended after the tailing dams bursts. It is not certain whether mining will be continued. The issue is now compensation for loss of life and reparations. Whether there will be a successful criminal case against the companies involved, Vale and BHP Billiton, and court decisions sending those responsible to jail, is yet not known.
Do you consider this an environmental justice success? Was environmental justice served?:No
Briefly explain:After the large spillage of tailings on 5th November 2015 from the failed dams there is negotiation on the compensation and there might be criminal lawsuit. This is a matter that will presumably last for years.

Sources and Materials

References to published books, academic articles, movies or published documentaries

BBC. Rebuilding lives after Brazil's 'worst mining accident'. Daniel Gallas. 20 nov 2015.
http://www.bbc.com/news/business-34849083

[5] Atingidos pela Vale. Mais um rastro de destruição e morte na história da mineração e da Vale S.A. 6 nov 2015.
https://atingidospelavale.wordpress.com/2015/11/06/mais-um-rastro-de-destruicao-e-morte-na-historia-da-mineracao-e-da-empresa-vale-s-a-nota-da-articulacao-internacional-dos-atingidos-e-atingidas-pela-vale-s-a/#more-1238

[14] IBAMA. Laudo Técnico Preliminar Impactos ambientais decorrentes do desastre envolvendo o rompimento da barragem de Fundão, em Mariana. Nov 2015.
https://www.ibama.gov.br/phocadownload/barragemdefundao/laudos/laudo_tecnico_preliminar_Ibama.pdf

[16] Rocha, D.S. As lutas indígenas em contextos de injustiças e conflitos ambientais: vida, saúde e mobilizações dos povos Tupinikim e Guarani Mbyá no Norte do Espírito Santo. Rio de Janeiro, Fiocruz (Tese) , 2017.
https://www.arca.fiocruz.br/handle/icict/24103

[10] Reuters. Vale workers fear for safety after Brazil's Samarco disaster. Marta Nogueira. 19 nov 2015.
http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/11/19/us-brazil-damburst-vale-sa-idUSKCN0T832U20151119

[9] Financial Times. Brazil mine disaster casts cloud over BHP Billiton and Vale. James Wilson, Jamie Smyth, Joe Leahy. 10 nov 2015.
https://www.ft.com/content/e3c28250-879a-11e5-9f8c-a8d619fa707c

Links to general newspaper articles, blogs or other websites

MAB - Audiência da Assembleia Legislativa discute impactos da Samarco. 17 nov 2015.
http://www.mabnacional.org.br/noticia/audi-ncia-da-assembleia-legislativa-discute-impactos-da-samarco

[1] Globo. Protesto de índios na estrada de Ferro Vitória a Minas completa 4 dias [Report on the actions against pollution of the Rio Doce by the Krenak indigenous people]. Mariana Oda. 16 nov 2015.
http://g1.globo.com/mg/vales-mg/noticia/2015/11/protesto-de-indios-na-estrada-de-ferro-vitoria-minas-completa-4-dias.html

[2] Folha de Sao Paulo. Brazil Dam Burst: Mud Advances and Provokes Fish Kill in Minas Gerais. Fábio Braga, Thiago Amâncio. 11 nov 2015.
http://www1.folha.uol.com.br/internacional/en/brazil/2015/11/1706986-brazil-dam-burst-mud-advances-and-provokes-fish-kill-in-minas-gerais.shtml

[3] Estado de São Paulo. Samarco passou a acumular mais rejeitos em 2014 nas barragens rompidas. [report in Estado de Sao Paulo on iron ore production and waste production by Samarco in 2014]. José Tomazela. 8 nov 2015.
http://www.estadao.com.br/noticias/geral,samarco-passou-a-acumular-mais-rejeitos-em-2014-nas-barragens-rompidas,1792688

MAB - MAB cobra comprometimento do MDA na reconstrução da Bacia do Rio Doce. 16 nov 2015.
http://www.mabnacional.org.br/noticia/mab-cobra-comprometimento-do-mda-na-reconstru-da-bacia-do-rio-doce

El Pais. Lama de barragem da Samarco chega ao mar. 25 nov 2015.
http://brasil.elpais.com/brasil/2015/11/23/album/1448301345_943414.html#1448301345_943414_1448301439

[12] MAB - Nota Pública: Juiz do caso Samarco: espetáculos, manobras e violação de direitos civis e políticos. 10 aug 2018.
http://www.mabnacional.org.br/noticia/nota-p-blica-juiz-do-caso-samarco-espet-culos-manobras-e-viola-direitos-civis-e-pol-ticos

[13] Globo - Justiça Federal homologa TAC quase 3 anos após rompimento de Fundão. 8 aug 2018.
https://g1.globo.com/mg/minas-gerais/noticia/2018/08/08/justica-federal-homologa-tac-quase-3-anos-apos-rompimento-de-fundao.ghtml

[11] Agência Brasil. Procuradores da tragédia de Mariana querem atuar no caso de Brumadinho. Léo Rodrigues. 31 jan 2019.
http://agenciabrasil.ebc.com.br/geral/noticia/2019-01/procuradores-da-tragedia-de-mariana-querem-atuar-no-caso-de-brumadinho

[15] Piauí. A onda: Uma reconstituição da tragédia de Mariana, o maior desastre ambiental do país. Consuelo Diegues. Jul 2016.
https://piaui.folha.uol.com.br/materia/a-onda-de-mariana/

[20] Globo. Justiça Federal retoma ação criminal que tornou acusados réus por homicídio no desastre de Mariana, diz MPF. 13 nov 2017.
https://g1.globo.com/minas-gerais/noticia/justica-federal-retoma-acao-criminal-que-tornou-acusados-reus-por-homicidio-no-desastre-de-mariana-diz-mpf.ghtml

Related media links to videos, campaigns, social network

[4] Tragédia anunciada – dossiê do Movimento Atingidos por Barragem (MAB) faz um balanço da situação em Mariana (MG) [Report by MAB]. 8 nov. 2015.
http://soscorpo.org/tragedia-anunciada-dossie-do-movimento-atingidos-por-barragem-mab-faz-um-balanco-da-situacao-em-mariana-mg/

[18] Atingidos pela Vale. NOTA CONTRA A HOMOLOGAÇÃO DO ACORDÃO DE MARIANA. 6 May 2016.
https://atingidospelavale.wordpress.com/2016/05/09/nota-contra-a-homologacao-do-acordao-de-mariana/#more-1318

[19] MAB. Nota Pública: Juiz do caso Samarco: espetáculos, manobras e violação de direitos civis e políticos. 10 aug 2018.
http://www.mabnacional.org.br/noticia/nota-p-blica-juiz-do-caso-samarco-espet-culos-manobras-e-viola-direitos-civis-e-pol-ticos

ABRASCO. Nota da Abrasco sobre a tragédia da mineração em MG: SAMARCO-VALE-BHP. 26.11.2015.
https://www.abrasco.org.br/site/outras-noticias/institucional/nota-da-abrasco-sobre-a-tragedia-da-mineracao-em-mg-samarco-vale-bhp/14904/

[17] Atingidos pela Vale. Nota da Articulação Internacional dos Atingidos e Atingidas pela Vale frente ao marco de um ano do maior crime socioambiental do país. 6 nov 2016.
https://atingidospelavale.wordpress.com/2016/11/06/nota-da-articulacao-internacional-dos-atingidos-e-atingidas-pela-vale-frente-ao-marco-de-um-ano-do-maior-crime-socioambiental-do-pais/

Other documents

Sanmarco tailings disaster Source: http://cobertura.brasildefato.com.br/
https://file.ejatlas.org/docs/Mariana_disaster.jpg

http://ggnnoticias.com.br/noticia/indios-fecham-ferrovia-da-vale-em-minas-gerais
https://file.ejatlas.org/docs/151115195209_indio_2_640x360_bbc_nocredit.jpg

Meta information

Contributor:Joan Martinez Alier
Last update22/02/2019

Images

 

http://ggnnoticias.com.br/noticia/indios-fecham-ferrovia-da-vale-em-minas-gerais

 

Samarco tailings disaster

Source: http://cobertura.brasildefato.com.br/